Who scores a city in Carcassonne when players have different numbers of meeple?
The player with the most meeple on a scored feature scores the full points, and the other players score nothing. If several players are tied for the most meeple, all of the tied players score the full points. A tie does not split the points; each tied player gets all of them.
Checked against Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN) on October 27, 2026
What the rulebook says
The player with the most meeple on a scored feature scores the full points; the others score nothing.
“If there are multiple meeple on a single scored feature, the player with the most meeple on the feature scores the”
— Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN), p. 5“you and only you score the 10 points for the completed city.”
— Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN), p. 6
If multiple players are tied for the most meeple, all tied players score the full points.
“If multiple players are tied for the most meeple, all tied players score the full points.”
— Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN), p. 5
You may place a meeple on a city segment that is not (yet) connected to another city segment with a meeple on it; a later tile can then join the segments into a single feature.
“city segment you placed a”
— Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN), p. 6“meeple on is not connected”
— Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN), p. 6“to another city segment”
— Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN), p. 6“with a meeple on it.”
— Carcassonne — Rulebook (EN), p. 6