In Oath, can Recover take the Darkest Secret from another player, and what does it cost?
Yes, but only if any card at that player's site does not match any of their advisers. Ruined edifices and facedown advisers are ignored for this check, and a player whose site has no cards cannot lose it. Recover costs 1 Supply, and the cost is any number of secrets greater than the number currently on the Darkest Secret.
Checked against Oath — Law of Oath (EN) on November 13, 2026
What the rulebook says
Recover can only take the Darkest Secret from another player if any card at that player's site does not match any of their advisers.
“if any card at the holder’s site does not match any of their”
— Oath — Law of Oath (EN), p. 6
Ruined edifices and facedown advisers are ignored for this check (they have no suit), and the Darkest Secret cannot be recovered from another player whose site has no cards.
“(Ignore ruined edifices and facedown advisers, since they have no”
— Oath — Law of Oath (EN), p. 6“their site has no cards or”
— Oath — Law of Oath (EN), p. 6
The cost is any number of secrets greater than the number currently on the Darkest Secret.
“of secrets greater than its current value.”
— Oath — Law of Oath (EN), p. 6
Recover costs 1 Supply.
“5.4.1 Step 1: Spend 1 Supply and Choose Target.”
— Oath — Law of Oath (EN), p. 6