What must you play in backgammon if you can play either number but not both?
You must play the larger number. If either number can be played but not both, the player must play the larger one. When only one number can be played, the player must play that number. When neither number can be used, the player loses his turn.
Checked against Backgammon — Rulebook (EN) on October 28, 2026
What the rulebook says
If either number can be played but not both, the player must play the larger one.
“play that number. Or if either number can”
— Backgammon — Rulebook (EN), p. 1“be played but not both, the player must”
— Backgammon — Rulebook (EN), p. 1“play the larger one. When neither number”
— Backgammon — Rulebook (EN), p. 1
When only one number can be played, the player must play that number.
“number can be played, the player must”
— Backgammon — Rulebook (EN), p. 1
When neither number can be used, the player loses his turn.
“can be used, the player loses his turn.”
— Backgammon — Rulebook (EN), p. 1