Where does a city go in Catan, and how many cities can you have?
Where a city goes: it always replaces one of your settlements, so you remove the settlement from the board and place the city where it was. How many cities: each player has only 4 cities and may not build more than those 4.
Checked against Catan — Rulebook (EN) on October 27, 2026
What the rulebook says
A city always replaces one of your settlements: you remove the settlement from the board and place the city where it was.
“Cities always replace settlements.”
— Catan — Rulebook (EN), p. 9“settlements from the board, return it to your player area, and place your city”
— Catan — Rulebook (EN), p. 9
Each player has only 4 cities and may not build more.
“You have 4 cities and may not build more.”
— Catan — Rulebook (EN), p. 9